Wine Folly Logo
Lifestyle

Recent Study Shows That Wine Ratings Hurt Consumers

- Updated

Wine Ratings people buying wine. Arm gash.
A recent study by the American Association of Wine Economics shows how Wine Ratings hurt consumers. In the study, they analyzed 44,808 wines from the Wine Spectator review database and found that wine ratings cause market price variation and consumer confusion. Not cool.

Traditional economics has shown that an increased ratio of educated consumers leads to market stabilization. However, in the wine market, an increase of reviews (education?) causes price fluctuation across the entire line of wines from a producer. For example, a wine which receives a favorable review is often overvalued by as much as 12%. Reviews create uneven pricing markets which leads to confusion and inflated prices. Similarly, a winery with an acclaimed wine will see higher demand for all of their wines, regardless of quality.

The data was pulled from over 20 years of wine ratings. Wineries with more critical reviews over a period of several years tend to have higher prices, especially in their low-end wines.

Since reviews are not standardized nor revealed publicly (you have to have a Wine Spectator membership to view), wine reviews are a way of controlling information about wine. Ever wonder why you never see point ratings on wines below a score of 88? Chances are you’re looking for wine ratings on a wine merchants website, so why would they display a wine rating in the 70’s or below.


What’s the solution? Learn why you like the wines you like. The region, producer, style, varietals; all of these factors can help you develop your own taste profile so that you can find similar wines you’ll enjoy. It’s your money, just know buying wine based on ratings is going to cost you!

Read the full study “The Detrimental Effect of Expert Opinion on Price-Quality Dispersion Evidence from the Wine Market” by Karl Storchmann, Alexander Mitterling & Aaron Lee.

Buy the Book - Get the Course!

Get the Wine 101 Course ($29 value) FREE with the purchase of Wine Folly: Magnum Edition.

Learn More

AboutMadeline Puckette

James Beard Award-winning author and Wine Communicator of the Year. I co-founded Wine Folly to help people learn about wine. @WineFolly

Cover Image for How To Become a Winemaker Extraordinaire (by Julien Fayard)

How To Become a Winemaker Extraordinaire (by Julien Fayard)

We asked consulting winemaker extraordinaire, Julien Fayard, to fill us in on what takes to do his job.

Read More
Cover Image for Study Offers A New Look at Alcohol and Your Brain

Study Offers A New Look at Alcohol and Your Brain

A new study has headlines shouting “wine will clean your brain!” So, what does this study really signify? Find out the real story.

Read More
Cover Image for Say Hello to Tardif, France’s New (Old) Wine Variety

Say Hello to Tardif, France’s New (Old) Wine Variety

Tardif is intriguing because it’s slow to ripen – a classic sign of a high-quality red grape variety. The wines has similarities to Syrah.

Read More
Cover Image for Wine From Tenerife – The Canary Islands

Wine From Tenerife – The Canary Islands

Discover the wines of Tenerife through Master Sommelier, Brian McClintic’s, passionate adventure.

Read More
Cover Image for Tracing the Roots of California’s Heritage Wines

Tracing the Roots of California’s Heritage Wines

A story about an unlikely hero (a plant pathologist) who saved California’s heritage vines from being wiped out.

Read More
Cover Image for Treasure Map of West Coast Syrah

Treasure Map of West Coast Syrah

The west coast of the United States offers several pristine climates for producing outstanding Syrah wine. See where they grow best and learn about the unique wines from each region.

Read More