Looking for clean wines? Let’s explore some of the fears around wine additives and sulfites and find out what’s actually giving you a headache.
Are “Clean Wines” Really Clean?
Many wines claim to be “clean” but are they? Also, are natural wines clean?
As we’ll soon find out, there’s very little transparency about this topic, and the truth goes into uncharted territory.
Feeling “Off” After Drinking Wine
In excess, any alcoholic beverage brings feelings of fatigue, headaches, nausea, and abdominal pain. However, some drinkers complain about the onset of these symptoms after just a glass or two of wine.
What is causing this?
The Ultimate Wine Gift
The collector's edition set of the James Beard Award-winning Wine Folly book.Learn More
That “off” feeling you get from wine might come by a group of compounds called biogenic amines.
What Are Biogenic Amines?
Biogenic amines are organic nitrogen compounds that emerge naturally during winemaking. They include compounds like histamine, tyramine, putrescine, and cadaverine.
You’ll find biogenic amines in many foods including processed fish, meat, cheese, and fermented things (such as beer, wine, and kimchi).
Higher levels of biogenic amines (especially histamine and tyramine) cause flushing, headaches, nausea, and fatigue.
One Extreme Example
In one case report, six individuals aged 22 to 27 went to the emergency room with alcohol-poisoning-like symptoms after drinking about 3 glasses of wine at a party. The wine was only 10.5% alcohol by volume (which is low), so it didn’t make sense that these individuals would be so ill.
After some microbiological testing, scientists found the wine contained “not negligible” levels of biogenic amines.
Which Wines Contain Biogenic Amines?
Unfortunately, there are no hard-and-fast rules to follow on avoiding wines with biogenic amines because there is very little data available. (read more about this below.)
What If You’re Sensitive to Biogenic Amines?
Some of us are sensitive to biogenic amines (including me, the author). We experience flushing or get headaches easily after just a few sips of wine. So, here’s some practical advice on what to do about it:
- Always drink a glass of water before you drink a glass of wine. This eliminates the possibility that you might be dehydrated.
- If you’re going to drink more than a glass of wine, stick to white, rosé, and sparkling wines instead of red wines. (more on this below.)
- Despite our fears associated with sulfites, wines that contain sulfites stop the creation of biogenic amines by controlling microbial growth.
- If you’re sniffing, it’s useful to note that wines with excessive putrid aromas often correspond to elevated biogenic amines. (keyword: “excessive.”)
- High acid wines (wines with low pH – under 3.3 pH) naturally resist the creation of biogenic amines.
- Try to limit your consumption of foods high in biogenic amines (aged cheeses, cured meats, processed fish) when drinking wine.
- Some people recommend taking an anti-histamine before drinking wine. We’d advise you to check with your doctor before trying this.
How Come No One Talks About Biogenic Amines?
Biogenic amines have been on science’s radar for a long time. Histamine was first identified as a mediator to allergic reactions in the early 1900s.
In wine, a study produced by the American Journal of Enology and Viticulture in 1983 tested wines for amine content and noticed that red wines contained more histamine than white wines.
After more research, we’ve learned that a winemaking process called malolactic fermentation (used in nearly all red wines and “buttery” Chardonnay) increases histamine levels in wine.
Why Is There No Regulation About This?
The European Union has discussed regulation of biogenic amines, but no legal limits have been set.
One of the reasons for this is a sheer lack of wine information available for researchers to learn more.
Certainly, some wineries take biogenic amines very seriously, compiling their own research and winemaking practices to produce both delicious and safe products. However, wineries aren’t required to share this information with the public.
For Now, Clean Wines = Marketing Fluff
It might be wise to feel skeptical of wines marketed as “clean” unless the brands share their hard numbers.
Additionally, just because a wine is “natural” doesn’t mean it has lower biogenic amines. In fact, in certain scenarios, native fermentations can increase the likeliness of compounds like histamine and tyramine to form.
So, the next time you read a bold statement about how a wine is good for you, just remember wine is folly! Welcome to the party 😉
Should consumers have access to this information? Leave a comment below!